Estimated reading time: 6 minutes
Hiring staff is one of the most meaningful investments a church can make.
It’s not just a financial decision — it’s a ministry decision.
Every time you bring someone onto your team, you are investing in people who will shepherd, organize, teach, serve, and care for others. That’s sacred work. And it deserves thoughtful planning.
However, many church leaders unintentionally underestimate the true cost of hiring an employee by focusing only on salary.
When unexpected expenses arise later, it can create budget stress and uncomfortable conversations.
The solution isn’t fear — it’s understanding.
When you understand total compensation, you gain clarity. And clarity leads to wise stewardship, sustainable growth, and healthier ministry.
Let’s walk through what “total compensation” really means.
Salary Is Just the Starting Point
When most leaders consider hiring someone, they ask:
“Can we afford a $50,000 salary?”
But salary is only one piece of the picture.
Total compensation includes every financial investment the church makes on behalf of that employee.
Once you see the full picture, you can budget confidently rather than reactively.
This doesn’t mean staffing is too expensive. It means staffing deserves careful planning — because people matter.
Paid Time Off
Paid time off (PTO) typically includes:
- Vacation
- Sick leave
- Holidays
- Personal days
- Sabbatical Leave
Some leaders view PTO as “lost productivity.”
But in ministry, rest is not optional — it is Biblical.
Healthy staff members serve better and stay longer.
When you offer three or four weeks of PTO, you are building sustainability into your team. You are saying, “We want you to thrive here.”
Financially, PTO represents paid compensation for time not worked.
For example, four weeks of PTO equals roughly 8% of annual pay.
That cost should be included in planning — not as a negative, but as a wise investment in long-term ministry health.
Burned-out staff cost far more than well-rested staff.
Retirement Contributions
Many churches provide retirement benefits.
Employer contributions vary as a percentage of salary, often with a matching program.
If an employee earns $50,000 annually:
- A 5% contribution equals $2,500 per year
- A 10% contribution equals $5,000 per year
Retirement benefits communicate something powerful: “We care about your future.”
Many ministry employees sacrifice higher pay in the marketplace to serve the local church.
Offering retirement contributions is one way to demonstrate that their long-term well-being matters.
It’s not just compensation — it’s honor.
Health Benefits
Health insurance is often the largest non-salary expense for churches.
Coverage may include:
- Medical insurance
- Dental insurance
- Vision insurance
- Health savings account (HSA) contributions
Family coverage can range from $15,000 to $25,000 annually, depending on region and plan selection.
That number can feel overwhelming at first glance. But consider what it represents: peace of mind.
When a staff member knows their family is covered during illness or emergency, they are freed to focus on ministry rather than financial fear.
Providing health benefits builds loyalty, stability, and retention.
Payroll Taxes: The Often-Forgotten Line Item
Churches also pay employer payroll taxes, including:
- The employer portion of Social Security and Medicare (7.65%)
- Federal and state unemployment taxes (where applicable)
Clergy have a unique Social Security tax treatment, but churches still need to understand how payroll is structured to avoid surprises.
These costs aren’t glamorous — but they are predictable. When included upfront in budgeting, they eliminate future stress.
Other Benefits
Additional benefits may include:
- Continuing education allowances
- Conference or ministry travel
- Mileage reimbursement
- Cell phone stipends
- Life insurance
- Disability insurance
Individually, these expenses may seem minor. Together, they meaningfully increase total compensation.
More importantly, they equip your staff to grow and serve effectively.
Continuing education strengthens preaching. Conferences inspire innovation. Travel supports collaboration. These aren’t perks — they are ministry tools.
What Does Total Compensation Look Like in Real Numbers?
Let’s look at a practical example.
Assume a church hires an employee at a $50,000 base salary.
Here is a possible breakdown:
- Base Salary: $50,000
- Retirement (5%): $2,500
- Health Insurance: $18,000
- Payroll Taxes (7.65%): $3,825
- Other Benefits: $3,000
Total Compensation Cost: $77,325
That $50,000 position actually costs the church over $77,000 annually.
That’s about 54% more than salary alone.
If leaders budget only for salary, they will quickly feel financial pressure.
But if they plan for total compensation from the beginning, staffing becomes sustainable.
Why Understanding This Is Important
This information is not meant to discourage hiring.
It’s meant to empower wise leadership.
When you understand total compensation:
- You budget realistically.
- You avoid reactive cuts.
- You communicate clearly with boards and finance teams.
- You make confident hiring decisions.
- You build a stable and healthy ministry culture.
Instead of saying, “We can’t afford staff,” you can say, “Here is what it truly costs — and here is how we plan for it.”
That shift changes everything.
Staff Are Not Expenses
It’s easy to look at compensation as a line item.
But every staff member represents expanded ministry capacity:
- More people cared for
- More volunteers mobilized
- More systems strengthened
- More lives impacted
When you invest in staff wisely, you multiply your church’s ability to fulfill its mission.
The key is not to minimize compensation — it’s to plan for it.
Hiring church staff is one of the most strategic decisions you will make.
Don’t let an incomplete understanding of finances create unnecessary fear.
Instead, embrace total compensation as a stewardship tool. When you account for salary, benefits, taxes, and long-term care, you are honoring both your budget and your people.
Healthy churches plan carefully.
Healthy churches compensate fairly.
Healthy churches think long-term.
And when you do, you create a ministry environment where people can serve faithfully — not just for a season, but for years to come.
We have created an editable Excel worksheet that lets you instantly see the total compensation cost by automatically calculating it.
This tool allows you to enter your salary and housing allowance, calculate PTO values, retirement contributions, payroll taxes, and other benefits, and quickly provide a total cost.
If you are a member, you can log in and access the document here.
If you are not a member, you can access this document, as well as our growing library of other forms, documents, and job descriptions, by clicking here.
