Estimated reading time: 5 minutes
The COVID Pandemic has created more problems than any of us could have anticipated a year ago. One of those problems is dealing with church conflict.
Whether your church is located in an area that allows for church services, or you happen to be in an area that continues to have restrictions – everyone has an opinion.
Churches are scrambling to meet CDC guideline requirements while trying to balance meeting the needs of diverse populations of members.
If members don’t feel safe returning to church, they stay away. And, very often, those members are valuable volunteers who help to make church happen.
These are difficult situations for church leaders to navigate. Of course, we want to keep everyone safe, but how do you open church with a handful of people who are comfortable coming back?
Conflict resolution is a leadership competency that church leaders need to hone. Knowing how to navigate church conflict can minimize its spread and impact.
There is a common phenomenon in the church today.
People get offended, conflict arises, and people leave the church.
Very often, this is the result of miscommunication or no communication.
Church members are human, and when there is a gap in information, people tend to fill in the blanks.
And, oftentimes, what they fill the gap with is inaccurate or untrue.
I had a pastor recently share about a member who left the church because they didn’t agree with a purchase that was made – a purchase that was approved by the board.
The sad thing about it was this church member didn’t confront the pastor or the board about the situation but shared their displeasure with another church member, who was brave enough to let the pastor know.
Much of the struggle with situations like this, comes from the reality that members pay tithes to support the church and have an interest in what those tithes are spent on.
The challenge is to display transparency in every church decision and be diligent with communicating – over, and over, and over again.
No one likes conflict, but it does not necessarily have to be a bad thing.
It can be a good thing when it is a symptom of discontent and if it ultimately results in a positive change.
In this example, the lesson learned was the decision should have been communicated and explained to eliminate the misunderstanding.
3 Ways to Manage Church Conflict
1. Communicate, Communicate, Communicate
In this season of COVID, good communication is key!
Members may disagree with how the church is handling the pandemic.
But, when they understand why the church does what it does, they are more apt to support decisions.
I’m a firm believer that many problems can be avoided by clear, intentional, and consistent communication.
For church leaders, this means creating a communication process to flow information throughout the organization.
One way to do this is when a decision is made, have a process in place to share that information with employees (staff meeting), volunteers (volunteer meetings or email blast), and church members (church meetings or Sunday announcements).
The goal is to share information before it hits the rumor mill and goes viral.
It is much easier to control what is communicated on the front end than cleaning up rumors on the back end.
Once the information is shared, have a process that addresses any issues or concerns.
For example, provide a Q&A after a major announcement is made.
This simple step allows people the opportunity to voice concerns or ask questions for clarity.
No one likes to get blindsided and caught off guard by unanticipated concerns – especially publicly!
As a caution, think through any anticipated questions so you are prepared to answer them.
2. Confront The Issue
Most of us don’t enjoy conflict, but the best way to handle church conflict is to confront it head-on.
There is a theory in conflict resolution that suggests that the longer a conflict festers, the less likely there will be a positive outcome.
This makes it vital to confront the issues as soon as possible.
The unfortunate outcome of some situations is that when a member is upset with something, they often share this discontent with another member, and this gossip cycle can be very damaging.
It is so fascinating to watch how a very content person can become malcontent when someone engages them in negativity and gossip.
This is the time to confront the individual and work to clarify information, understanding of the situation, and try to resolve the issue.
Don’t make the mistake or ignoring it. Gossip can run through a church quickly and needs to be stopped!
3. Provide A Structured Feedback Process
Whenever there is more than one person in a room, there is the opportunity for conflict.
We are all wired differently and come from different backgrounds, so we will each see things from a unique perspective.
The challenge for church leaders, in the example above, is it is very difficult to confront an issue if you aren’t even aware of the situation.
Create a comfortable feedback process for employees, volunteers, and members and make it easy and safe for them to share issues or concerns.
An easy process provides a convenient and a safe environment that allows for disagreements to be discussed and debated openly.
Creating systems for communication and transparency in big decisions can be a first step in developing a culture that seeks not to eliminate conflict but to manage it.